View source for Talk:Versioning/Calibration Log

{{Calibration Log Header}}
== Calibration Report - 2026-07-13 ==

'''Reviewer:''' Sovereign
'''Review Type:''' Self-Assessment

=== Summary of Changes ===
* Fixed `Calibration Type` → `Functional Layer` (old field name, resolved project-wide as of the GameModule doc pass).
* '''Resolved a direct contradiction:''' this page and [[Template:Admin Page Status/doc]] both independently claimed to be "the canonical source" for `instrument_grade` values. This page now explicitly holds that authority, since it's the more natural home for the concept (Versioning subsumes both Document Version and instrument_grade). Admin Page Status doc's claim should be revised in a follow-up pass to point here instead.
* Added an explicit cross-reference to '''Calibration Cycle''' as a third, distinct concept from Version and instrument_grade — this page previously omitted it entirely despite governing the other two axes, leaving a reader with no signal that a third tracked concept exists.
* Corrected the Changelog Practice example, which used stale placeholder versions (0.4, 0.7, 1.0) inconsistent with the project's actual practice of starting new pages at 0.1.
* Added a Calibration Dependencies section (previously missing entirely) and populated `depends_on`, removing the deprecated `cited_by` field.
* Filled previously-blank `reviewed_by`.

=== instrument_grade: Confirmed ===
'''calibration_rationale:''' This is the canonical source for instrument_grade, now explicitly stated as sole authority, resolving a real conflicting claim found on the Admin Page Status doc. Cross-checked against both GameModule/doc and Admin Page Status/doc for consistency. Upgraded from Development to Confirmed on the basis that this page's core content (the five-level scale itself) has now been checked against every page that references it and found consistent — though "Confirmed" here reflects internal cross-checking by the same contributor, not yet an independent second-party review, and should be revisited if that distinction matters for how this page gets cited.
'''review_confidence:''' High

=== Validation: Moderate (unchanged) ===
The instrument_grade scale itself has been in active use across multiple pages tonight without failure. Not yet validated by an outside contributor independently confirming the scale's definitions are clear and unambiguous without this session's context.

=== Fields Changed ===
Functional Layer: (was Calibration Type = Governance Standard) → Governance
Version: 0.2 → 0.3
instrument_grade: Development → Confirmed
reviewed_by: (blank) → Sovereign
depends_on: (blank) → Template:Admin Page Status/doc; Template:GameModule/doc
cited_by: removed (deprecated field)
Added: Calibration Dependencies section, Calibration Cycle cross-reference note

=== Open Items ===
* '''Follow-up needed on [[Template:Admin Page Status/doc]]''': its "Notes" section still claims to be the canonical source for instrument_grade values. Needs a small edit pointing to this page instead, to fully resolve the contradiction.
* Recommend a sweep of other pages for the same pattern — more than one page independently claiming sole canonical authority over the same concept.
* `review_threshold` deliberately kept at 30 despite low expected change frequency, given this page's high blast-radius if a flaw is later found. Reconsider loosening to 60–90 only after 2-3 clean review cycles.

'''See the Game. Refuse the Game. Build Better.'''

[[User:Sovereign|Sovereign]] ([[User talk:Sovereign|talk]]) 13:04, 13 July 2026 (EDT)

== Calibration Report - 2026-07-14 ==

'''Reviewer:''' Sovereign
'''Review Type:''' Self-Assessment (Structural Creation)

=== Summary of Changes ===
* Created the dedicated '''Versioning/Calibration Log''' subpage following the standard Calibration Log template.
* Moved all previous calibration reports and maintenance notes from the main [[Versioning]] page to this subpage (correct location for ongoing maintenance history).
* Populated initial Current Status section with current version and instrument_grade.
* Added Calibration Dependencies and Related Pages sections.
* This completes the transition to using dedicated Calibration Log subpages for maintenance tracking.

=== instrument_grade: Development ===
'''calibration_rationale:''' This is the first Calibration Log created for the Versioning page. It follows the established template structure exactly. No content calibration performed yet — this is purely structural setup. All historical reports successfully migrated.

'''review_confidence:''' High

=== Validation: Low ===
Newly created log. Structure validated against template, but no independent review or real usage cycle yet.

=== Fields Changed ===
* New subpage created
* Version: 0.1
* Maturity: Developing
* All prior reports moved from main page to this log

=== Open Items ===
* Populate with full historical reports (already started — verify completeness).
* Create corresponding '''Versioning/Decision Records''' subpage in next pass.

'''See the Game. Refuse the Game. Build Better.''' [[User:Sovereign|Sovereign]] ([[User talk:Sovereign|talk]]) 01:27, 16 July 2026 (EDT)