View source for Talk:Breadcrumb Philosophy

== Calibration Report - 2026-07-13 (v0.2) ==

'''Reviewer:''' Sovereign
'''Review Type:''' Self-Assessment, informed by multi-model review (ChatGPT, Grok)

=== Summary of Changes ===
* Added opening thesis sentence ("Calibration is not only about recording what we know...") ahead of the mechanical definitions, per ChatGPT's suggestion — states the philosophy before the how-to, matching the pattern already used on the Standards taxonomy page.
* Added a new '''Types of Breadcrumbs''' section distinguishing Permanent, Temporary, and Trigger breadcrumbs — closes a real gap where the page implied all breadcrumbs resolve the same way. Trigger breadcrumbs specifically now carry a stated expectation that they get removed once their condition is met, rather than lingering indefinitely.
* Added a forward-looking vs. historical distinction under Relationship to Other Mechanisms, clarifying why breadcrumbs live in-page rather than in a Report or Decision Record.
* Expanded Calibration Dependencies from 2 entries to 4, adding Template:Admin Page Status/doc and Standards: Types and Calibration Obligations, both genuinely referenced in the page's content but previously missing from the dependency list.

=== Process Note: Stale-Context Review Detected ===
Grok's review (points 1–3: Title vs. Content, Standard Lifecycle, consolidated Open Items) referenced content — "Required triplet," "Standard Lifecycle," Personal Standards as an open item — that does not exist anywhere on this page. That content belongs to [[Standards: Types and Calibration Obligations]], a separate page reviewed earlier in the same session. This is the '''second instance''' this session of a reviewer apparently working from a stale, paraphrased, or conflated version of a page rather than its literal current text (first instance: Grok re-requesting items already present in a prior Standards taxonomy draft).

'''No content change made in response to points 1–3''' — they don't apply to this page. Point 4 (thin Calibration Dependencies) was legitimate and independent of the mix-up, and was addressed.

'''Recommendation for future round-robin process:''' always paste the literal, current, full page text before requesting review — do not rely on a reviewer's memory of a similar or recently-discussed page, especially now that multiple pages share overlapping vocabulary (breadcrumbs, open items, taxonomy language).

=== instrument_grade: Development (unchanged) ===
'''calibration_rationale:''' Real improvements adopted from genuine, applicable feedback (ChatGPT's thesis statement and breadcrumb-types taxonomy). Not upgraded to Confirmed, since — unlike the Standards taxonomy page — this page has not yet been deliberately applied to a new page from scratch as a test of whether the guidance is actually usable in practice, only reviewed in the abstract.
'''review_confidence:''' Moderate

=== Validation: Low (unchanged) ===
No new field-use evidence this pass — content review and refinement only. Still awaiting a real test: applying this exact guidance to a new page being built from scratch, and checking whether the resulting breadcrumbs are actually clear and useful to someone other than the author.

=== Fields Changed ===
Version: 0.1 → 0.2
depends_on: Reality Override Game → Reality Override Game; Template:Admin Page Status/doc; Standards: Types and Calibration Obligations

=== Open Items ===
* Not yet tested by deliberate application to a new page.
* No other existing pages have been retrofitted to link back here yet, despite most of them already following this practice informally (flagged as a future task, not urgent).
* Process note above should inform how round-robin reviews are conducted going forward — worth referencing in whatever page eventually documents the round-robin process itself, if one gets built.

'''See the Game. Refuse the Game. Build Better.'''

[[User:Sovereign|Sovereign]] ([[User talk:Sovereign|talk]]) 17:26, 14 July 2026 (EDT)

== Calibration Report — Breadcrumb Philosophy — 2026-07-20 (Structural Pre-Cal) ==

* **Page:** [[Breadcrumb Philosophy]]
* **Summary:** Structural pre-calibration pass. Four nonconformances found and corrected.
* **Reviewer:** Sovereign
* **Review Type:** Self-Assessment (Structural only)

**Summary of Changes:**
* Changed to canonical `| Calibration Type =`.
* Added required inline HTML comments on all fields.
* Added the four missing mandatory templates.
* Made Resource block visible (removed `display:none` wrapper).
* Corrected template order.

**Process Note:**  
Nonconformances were logged before fixes were applied.

**What This Report Does NOT Claim:**  
No content calibration was performed.

'''See the Game. Refuse the Game. Build Better.''' [[User:Sovereign|Sovereign]] ([[User talk:Sovereign|talk]]) 09:51, 20 July 2026 (EDT)