View source for Promotion & Traceability Regime (Seed)

{{Development Notice
|position = Core regime · Traceability
|cycle = Seed
|status = Self-Assessed
}}

= Promotion & Traceability Regime =
'''One line:'''  
'''Bench creates. Lab certifies. Top exhibits. Change always returns to Bench.'''  
Traceability is required '''now''' — not only as a future ideal. This regime ''is'' how the lab establishes it.
{{GameModule
| type = Core Principle
| category = [[:Category:Meta & Framework|Meta & Framework]]
| Calibration Type = Lab governance / Traceability
| Application Layer = Bench · Lab · Top · Dictionary · External labs
| Version = 0.1
| Maturity = Foundational (Seed standing)
| Last Updated = 2026-07-30
| description = Promotion and traceability regime: Bench creates, Lab certifies, Top exhibits; change returns to Bench. Own certificate authority under published rules; scrutiny and metrology as the answerability standard. Dictionary as trust surface. Traceability required now.
}}

== 1. Authority under our own rules (and what that does not mean) ==

National institutes (e.g. NIST) do '''not''' negate this lab’s authority to define '''how certificates and claim types work under MoA procedures'''.

{| class="wikitable"
! We claim
! We do not claim
|-
| Authority to set '''regime rules''' for promotion, freeze, standing labels, and how others may claim “certified under this regime”
| Ownership of any domain’s '''Domain SI''' (statutes, plant SOPs, OSI text, etc.)
|-
| Answerability to '''scrutiny, transparency, and metrology practice'''
| Freedom from challenge, friction, or independent re-runs
|-
| Right to refuse Bench “we’re done” when procedure is not met
| Monopoly on all abstract calibration worldwide
|-
| Portable procedures others may adopt or fork under '''their''' standing
| That adoption = our endorsement unless claim type says so
|}

'''We answer to no ministry for permission to run this chain.'''  
We answer to '''scrutiny, transparency, and metrology itself''' — the same family of pressure serious measurement culture already accepts.

NIST-class posture is '''cousin''', not master of our certificate rules. Dual non-ownership remains: Domain SI stays with the domain; '''certs stay with the chain that issued them'''.

== 2. Why traceability now ==

Traceability is not a later prestige feature. Without it:

Public artifacts point at moving Bench pages  
“Certified” becomes a vibe  
Re-cal and audit cannot find the freeze  
External labs cannot plug in without chaos  

'''This regime establishes traceability for present use''' — operators, AI retrieve, competing labs, and future history. The future of the lab ''is'' this chain running today under Seed standing until friction improves it.

== 3. Three layers ==

{| class="wikitable"
! Layer
! Name
! Function
! Public trust role
|-
| '''Bench'''
| Workbench / sandbox (e.g. TSG shop)
| Draft, argue, test, Permanent Beta, structural mess, Calibration Debt
| '''None as certificate''' — may be public as bench, never as cert authority
|-
| '''Lab'''
| Calibration lab
| Review, improve or refuse, issue freeze/cert under published procedures
| '''Certificate authority''' for artifacts it accepts under this regime
|-
| '''Top'''
| Authority / standards face
| Host certified freezes, maps, deep-dives; prefer fast static or static-generated
| '''Exhibition only''' — never performs calibration
|}

Aligns with three surfaces (root / cal lab / shop) without requiring a specific vendor stack. Roles matter more than software brands.

== 4. Workflow ==

BENCH
   Develop until promotion is requested
   (candidate complete enough to ask Lab — not “public ready by vibes”)
   Good enough, better than hit or miss — honest level and standing

LAB
   Review against published procedures + this regime
   · Accept → improve if needed → certify / freeze record
   · Refuse → return to Bench with reasons
   Lab does not owe acceptance of Bench’s “we’re done.”

TOP
   Publish only Lab-certified artifacts
   No live calibration on Top
   No silent mutation of certified text

CHANGE / RE-CAL
   Signal (field use, cycle, error, regime rule, regime shift)
   → Bench rework
   → Lab re-cert
   → Top replaces prior freeze (prior freeze remains in history)
   Never edit Top as if it were Bench

== 5. Mandatory metadata (every certified / Top artifact) ==

'''Regime identity''' — under which certification structure  
'''Lab identity''' — who certified (this lab or external lab under regime rules)  
'''Procedure / standard IDs + versions''' used  
'''Artifact version + freeze date'''  
'''Standing / result summary''' as lab procedures define  
'''Pointer to Lab record''' — not to Bench talk, open breadcrumb farms, or Active Development as the cert target  
'''Claim type''' (e.g. MoA Lab path vs independent self-cal under guidelines) when applicable  

No public trust artifact points at uncertified draft state as if it were the freeze.

== 6. What each layer must not do ==

{| class="wikitable"
! Layer
! Forbidden
|-
| '''Bench'''
| Issue public certs under this regime; act as Top; present draft as freeze
|-
| '''Lab'''
| Point certs at uncertified Bench pages as the authority URL; skip published procedure; seize Domain SI
|-
| '''Top'''
| Perform calibration; silently revise certified text; host drafts as authority face
|}

== 7. Dictionary — trust surface, not workbench ==

'''Prior mental model:''' Dictionary as Bench module → '''wrong.'''  

Dictionary is a '''trust surface''': definitions people will treat as reference. That is '''Lab + Top''' territory for canonical URLs.

{| class="wikitable"
! Aspect
! Where
|-
| Drafting terms, disputes, alternatives
| '''Bench''' (staging / working area)
|-
| Accepted definition, version, cert status
| '''Lab''' (review + certify)
|-
| Public lookup, clean UX, stable URLs
| '''Top''' (or Top-facing hybrid) fed only by certified entries
|}

'''Hybrid Dictionary model:'''

'''Public face:''' clean lookup, stable URLs, reads like a reference instrument — not an edit war.  
'''Lab cert:''' each published entry carries regime metadata (who certified, version, date, procedure).  
'''Outside labs:''' may submit or co-certify '''only''' through Lab gates under this regime — not by editing the public face directly.  
'''Bench:''' proposals and dispute history linked as development trail — not the canonical definition URL.

'''Rule:''' Canonical dictionary URL never resolves to “edit this page / unresolved breadcrumb farm” as the authority object. It resolves to '''certified text + cert trail'''.

== 8. Outside labs (welcome, not chaos) ==

Open to external calibration labs '''under this regime''' (shared or adopted procedures, standing rules, evidence bar).  
They do not become a second Top.  
They issue or co-sign through '''Lab process'''; Top only exhibits what the regime has certified.  
Independent operators may still run '''self-cal under public guidelines''' (claim type distinct) without becoming regime Lab — honesty of claim type required.  
Prevents both closed priesthood and “anyone pastes into the dictionary.”

== 9. Relationship to other doctrine ==

[[Domain SI — We Calibrate, We Do Not Set]] — regime authority ≠ Domain SI ownership  
[[Doctrine: Good Enough, Better Than Hit or Miss]] — Lab may certify lower levels when the abstract caps depth; underclaim required  
[[Seed to Fruit Development]] — Bench seeds; Lab/Top fruit for trust URLs  
[[Developer Note: Domains, Not Initiatives]] — need-based promotion, not campaign theater  
[[Developer Note: Three Surfaces]] — root / cal / shop roles  
Claim types & map guidelines — self-cal ≠ Lab cert  

== 10. Stack note (non-normative) ==

Roles are normative. Software is not:

Top often fits '''static or static-generated''' HTML for speed and a calm face  
Lab needs '''stable cert records''' (wiki namespace, repo, or later systems) — not necessarily a client portal on day one  
Bench fits '''wiki / workbench''' collaboration  

Implement with tools that preserve the chain. Do not delay the regime for architecture theater.

== 11. One-line regime ==

'''Authority to label certificates under this regime runs on a defined chain: Bench produces candidates; Lab grants standing under published procedures; Top only shows what Lab has frozen; dictionary is a certified reference product; traceability starts now; we answer to scrutiny, transparency, and metrology — not to permission from another institute.'''

'''See the map. Pressure the map. Report the fit. Do not seize the Domain SI.'''  
'''Bench creates. Lab certifies. Top exhibits. Change returns to Bench.'''

[[Category:Meta & Framework]]
[[Category:Core Principles]]
[[Category:Seed]]